The following essay was written for the John F. Kennedy Profiles in Courage essay contest 2023, but was not submitted. It was finalized on January 12th, 2023.
With the outbreak of war in Ukraine, the world is once again facing bloody fighting. We are forced to reevaluate the value of peace, the horror of conflict—and the plight of wartime refugees around the planet.
In these troubling times, we must look to the past to see the plight of refugees, and how we as a nation must find the courage to help them. No elected official demonstrates this courage better than William Warren Barbour: business leader, heavyweight boxer, New Jersey Senator, and an outspoken advocate for Jews persecuted under the Nazi regime.
It is important to note that the US in the 1930s was highly antisemitic. Perhaps the most vivid illustration of this hatred comes from the pro-Nazi rally in Madison Square Garden in 1939, held by the German American Bund. Said Fritz Kuhn, the leader of the Bund: “Wake up! You, Aryan, Nordic and Christians, to demand that our government be returned to the people who founded it!” (Kramer). Indeed, according to the Anti-Defamation League, “daily antisemitic violence plagued Jews in the streets of some major American cities… where antisemitism thrived” (ADL).
Within this climate, it is surprising that Barbour chose to speak out on behalf of the persecuted Jews of Europe. Politicians accused of “Jewry” were subject to violent antisemitic accusations. During the German American Bund’s pro-Nazi rally at Madison Square Garden, for instance, “The cheers turned to jeers and boos… as other speakers mentioned President Roosevelt—made to sound as though it were spelled ‘Rosenfeld’—Harry Hopkins and others who had been outspoken in their denunciation of Nazi Germany” (NYT). Dr. Rafael Medoff says that “‘…Barbour had very little to gain politically… He was not up for re-election this year. He was not Jewish. He had no special connection to Jewish refugees” (Palmer). Barbour had nothing to gain.
What is more surprising is that Barbour himself had not previously shown much emotion for the plight of the European Jews. Indeed, “During his years on Capitol Hill, Barbour was not known to have any particular interest in matters of specifically Jewish concern, nor was foreign policy his specialty. Yet the plight of Europe’s Jews aroused his humanitarian sympathies” (Palmer).
One reason for his change of heart may be attributed to the screening of We Will Never Die, a musical pageant that raised awareness of the mass murder of millions of Jews in Europe. According to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, “Its audience members included… more than two hundred members of Congress [emphasis added]…” (USHMM). Although Barbour’s presence at the pageant cannot be ascertained, it may be that he found sympathy for the Jews after watching it.
Whatever the reason for his change was, Barbour clearly felt very strongly about this issue, demonstrated by an astounding act in the fall of 1943, when he met with 400 rabbis participating in the Rabbis’ March on Washington, D.C. The Jewish Historical Society of New Jersey says that Barbour “… was one of a small group of senators and congressmen who… met with 400 rabbis who marched.…” (JHSNJ).
It was no small gesture. According to the Association for Jewish Studies, “… more than four hundred Orthodox rabbis marched to the White House to plead with President Franklin D. Roosevelt to rescue European Jews from the Nazis….” (Medoff). Considering the political and social climate of the time, it was unusual for Barbour to so openly express his support for the Jewish cause. Indeed, it was a profoundly courageous decision.
Today, the march is noted for President Roosevelt’s decision to ignore the rabbis—in fact, Roosevelt was so opposed to meeting the rabbis that he “… avoided seeing the marchers by slipping out of the White House through a rear exit” (Medoff). Arthur Hertzberg, a participant in the march, said that “All of us who had been there that day left feeling very bitter…” (Hertzberg). Despite this setback, however, Barbour was determined to continue his cause.
To accomplish this, Barbour undertook the most courageous act of his political career: on October 14, 1943, he submitted Senate Joint Resolution 85 to the Committee on Immigration. The goal of the resolution was “To provide for the admission to the United States of aliens who are religious or racial refugees” (U.S. Senate). Had the resolution passed, “ …up to 100,000 victims of Axis persecution, because of religious faith or race, would be permitted to enter the United States as visitors for the duration of the war…” (New York Times).
According to the David S. Wyman Institute, “It took real political courage for Barbour to introduce such a resolution” (Medoff). Barbour’s resolution could have hardly been politically expedient in such an antisemitic climate.
However, tragedy struck when, just before Thanksgiving 1943, Barbour suffered a fatal heart attack. He was 55 years old. Without him, support for the resolution fizzled out, and it ultimately did not pass.
Congress mourned the loss of a great statesman. Vice President Henry A. Wallace said of him: “In his passing the Jewish people of Europe have sustained a great loss” (Congress). Representative Gordon Canfield remarked that “Senator Barbour… aimed to add to the sum of human happiness and he did” (Congress).
Even today, Barbour—and his courageous stand for justice—is not forgotten. The Jewish Historical Society of New Jersey states that “Senator Barbour’s actions did much to increase political and public awareness of and compassion for the victims of the genocide” (JHSNJ); the Jewish Standard called his legacy “A legacy of goodness” (Palmer). Dr. Rafael Medoff says that the Jewish community “gave thanks that in Jewry’s darkest hour, there were still men of courage who refused to be silent” (Medoff).
William Warren Barbour is a striking example of astounding political bravery at a time when such bravery was detrimental. Barbour stood up for the vulnerable, demonstrating courage for justice and empathy for the persecuted. The legacy of William Warren Barbour still lasts as one of compassion, courage, and kindness.
Bibliography
Kramer, Sarah Kate. “When Nazis Took Manhattan.” NPR, NPR, 20 Feb. 2019, www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2019/02/20/695941323/when-nazis-took-manhattan.
“Antisemitism in American History.” Antisemitism Uncovered, Anti-Defamation League, 27 Feb. 2020, antisemitism.adl.org/antisemitism-in-american-history/.
“22,000 NAZIS HOLD RALLY in GARDEN; POLICE CHECK FOES; SCENES as GERMAN-AMERICAN BUND HELD ITS “WASHINGTON BIRTHDAY” RALLY LAST NIGHT.” New York Times, TimesMachine, 21 Feb. 1939, timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1939/02/21/94680980.html
Palmer, Joanne. “A Legacy of Goodness.” Jewish Standard, Times of Israel, 31 Oct. 2019, jewishstandard.timesofisrael.com/a-legacy-of-goodness/.
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. “The ‘We Will Never Die’ Pageant.” Holocaust Encyclopedia, United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, 17 Sep. 2021, encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/the-we-will-never-die-pageant.
“Senator W. Warren Barbour.” Jewish Historical Society of New Jersey, WordPress, https://jhsnj.wordpress.com/senator-w-warren-barbour/.
Medoff, Rafael. “The 1943 Jewish March on Washington, Through the Eyes of its Critics.” AJS Perspectives, Association for Jewish Studies, https://associationforjewishstudies.org/publications-research/ajs-perspectives/the-protest-issue/the-1943-jewish-march-on-washington-through-the-eyes-of-its-critics.
Hertzberg, Arthur. “They Day the Rabbis Marched.” David S. Wyman Institute for Holocaust Studies, 7 Jul. 2004, web.archive.org/web/20070927043354/http://www.wymaninstitute.org/special/rabbimarch/.
United States, Congress, Senate, Committee on Immigration. Senate Joint Resolution 85. GovInfo, https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GPO-CRECB-1943-pt13/pdf/GPO-CRECB-1943-pt13-2.pdf, 78th Congress, Senate Joint Resolution 85, introduced 14 Oct. 1943.
“MOVES FOR ADMISSION OF 100,000 REFUGEES.” New York Times, TimesMachine, 15 Oct. 1943, https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1943/10/15/85126488.html?pageNumber=21
United States, Congress. “Memorial Services Held in the House of Representatives and Senate of the United States, Together With Remarks Presented in Eulogy of William Warren Barbour, Late a Senator form New Jersey.” United States Government Printing Service, Google Books, https://books.google.com/books?id=3koYAAAAYAAJ&printsec=frontcover&source=gbs_ge_summary_r&cad=0#v=onepage&q&f=false.